There’s a particular conversation that happens in therapists’ offices, in late-night phone calls between friends, in the quiet moments of self-honesty that arrive when a relationship has finally gotten bad enough that denial is no longer sustainable. The conversation usually starts with some version of the same question: “But if he really tried, if he actually wanted to change, he could, right?”
The answer to that question is complicated in ways that feel deeply unsatisfying when you’re in the middle of hoping for something different. Yes, people can change. Yes, men with these patterns have, in documented cases, with sustained professional help and genuine commitment, developed more emotional maturity over time. Yes, growth is possible in the abstract.
And also: he’s probably not going to change. Not because he’s a monster. Not because he’s irredeemably broken. But because the patterns you’re dealing with were years in the making, serve a purpose he doesn’t fully understand, have been consistently reinforced by the people around him including you, and would require him to commit to a kind of sustained discomfort he has no particular motivation to pursue, especially when the current arrangement, from where he’s standing, works reasonably well.
This isn’t a counsel of despair. It’s a counsel of clarity. Understanding why change is unlikely with a BBMB, and under what specific circumstances it becomes more possible, is some of the most useful information you can have. Because the alternative is spending months or years of your life trying to love someone into a version of themselves they have no roadmap for becoming, which is one of the most exhausting and thankless ways to spend a human life.
How He Got Here
Nobody becomes a Bitch Boy Man Baby all at once. The patterns that make these men so difficult to be in relationships with didn’t arrive in adulthood, fully formed and ready to cause damage. They developed slowly, across years of childhood and adolescence, in environments that were often trying to do right by the boys they were raising and managed to do harm anyway.
Developmental psychologists who study emotional regulation, which is the ability to manage feelings and respond to situations proportionately rather than reactively, understand it to develop through a process that requires two things happening consistently over time. First, children need to experience difficult emotions, including frustration, disappointment, and the ordinary miseries of not always getting what they want. Second, they need the adults around them to respond to those emotions in ways that teach regulation rather than avoidance: acknowledging feelings without amplifying them, offering comfort without eliminating consequences, and modeling what it looks like to work through difficulty rather than be rescued from it.
When one or both of these conditions are missing, emotional development is interrupted. The adult who never learned to tolerate frustration as a child still cannot tolerate it. The man who was consistently shielded from consequences hasn’t developed the neural pathways or the practiced experience of working through difficulty. He’s not performing helplessness in the face of challenge. He genuinely doesn’t have the tools, because nobody made sure he built them.
This is one of the more important pieces of information for anyone who loves or has loved a BBMB. His patterns are not a choice, not exactly. They’re the behavioral residue of developmental experiences that left gaps where skills should have developed. This doesn’t make the behavior acceptable. It doesn’t obligate you to absorb the costs of his underdevelopment indefinitely. But it does mean that telling him to be different, expecting him to simply decide to be different, or loving him intensely enough that he becomes different are all approaches that misunderstand the actual problem.
He doesn’t need more love. He needs developmental work he should have done decades ago, in a therapeutic context designed for exactly that purpose, with a professional whose job it is to provide it. You are not that professional, and you cannot do that work for him.
The Role Patriarchy Played
Individual developmental history doesn’t explain the whole picture, because the BBMB isn’t a random occurrence. He’s a pattern, which means something is producing him at scale. That something is the way our culture raises boys.
Across most Western societies, boys receive a specific set of instructions about what emotional life is supposed to look like for men. Don’t cry. Don’t show weakness. Handle things yourself. Don’t need too much from people. Be tough. The emotional education girls typically receive, including vocabulary for feelings, practice with emotional expression, and the social expectation that relationships require emotional investment, is systematically withheld from boys under the guise of preparing them for manhood.
The consequences of this withholding are not subtle. Researchers studying male emotional development have found that many men reach adulthood with what’s called alexithymia: difficulty identifying and articulating their own emotional states. They know something is wrong, or something feels bad, but the more granular emotional literacy that would allow them to identify specifically what they’re feeling, where it comes from, and how to address it constructively often hasn’t been developed. Anger tends to be the exception, because anger was permitted, sometimes even celebrated, as an appropriate masculine emotional expression.
So the BBMB who erupts in rage over something small isn’t necessarily choosing rage over a more proportionate response. Rage might be the only emotional language he has. The BBMB who withdraws into sulking when hurt isn’t necessarily being strategic, at least not consciously. He may genuinely not know what he’s feeling well enough to express it differently. The BBMB who externalizes responsibility for everything that goes wrong may not be lying, exactly. He may not have developed the capacity for the kind of self-reflection that would let him see his own role clearly.
None of this makes the behavior less damaging to you. But it does clarify why appeals to reason, expressions of how much you’re hurting, or demonstrations of the impact of his behavior often fail to produce the change you’re hoping for. You’re speaking a language he doesn’t speak. Not because he couldn’t learn it, but because he never did, and learning it now would require accepting that there is a problem, which is precisely the thing his psychology is organized around avoiding.
The Function the Pattern Serves
The behavioral patterns that define a BBMB aren’t random. They cluster in specific ways because they serve a specific psychological function: protecting a fragile sense of self from the threat of inadequacy.
At the core of most BBMB psychology is a self-image that feels perpetually under threat. Not the stable, low-level insecurity that most people live with comfortably enough. A more volatile kind, where criticism isn’t registered as information but as attack, where failure doesn’t prompt adjustment but panic, where disagreement doesn’t invite discussion but triggers defensiveness. This fragility is almost always concealed beneath a performance of confidence, competence, or toughness, but it’s there, and it’s running the show in ways he may not be remotely aware of.
The behaviors we associate with BBMBs, the blame-shifting, the emotional withdrawal, the victim narratives, the inability to apologize genuinely, the need for constant validation, are all, at their core, protection strategies. They are the ways this person has learned to keep the threat of inadequacy at bay. If nothing is ever his fault, he can’t be inadequate. If he’s the victim, he can’t be the perpetrator. If he keeps you slightly off-balance, your perception of him remains manageable. If he exits before you can, he controls the narrative. Every maddening thing he does makes complete psychological sense when you understand what it’s protecting.
This is important for understanding why change is so difficult. The behaviors aren’t incidental. They’re load-bearing walls in his psychological architecture. Removing them would require him to expose the fragility underneath, to sit with the possibility of being inadequate, to tolerate the feelings that his entire behavioral repertoire is designed to avoid. That’s terrifying, even when the conscious mind has no idea that’s what’s happening. And it’s not something love, patience, or persistence from a partner can address, because a partner isn’t a therapist and a relationship isn’t a treatment.
Why You Thought You Could Fix It
Let’s be honest about something that doesn’t get said enough: the belief that you can fix a BBMB is not evidence that you are naive or foolish. It’s evidence that you are human, empathetic, and operating in a culture that has specifically prepared certain people to believe that love and effort can solve relational problems that are not actually about love or effort at all.
Women are socialized, with remarkable consistency, toward emotional caretaking. The instinct to understand why someone behaves badly, to look for the wound underneath the behavior, to maintain hope for the person someone might become: these aren’t weaknesses. They’re often genuine strengths. The problem is that they’re activated by exactly the kinds of behaviors that shouldn’t be accommodated.
The BBMB is often at his most compelling when he’s at his worst. The meltdown, followed by apparent remorse, followed by a version of himself that seems vulnerable and real and in need of the care you’re equipped to give, is one of the most effective sequences in the BBMB’s unintentional repertoire. It hooks the exact impulses that make you good at caring for people. It makes the relationship feel like meaningful, important work. It makes leaving feel like abandonment.
There’s also the investment problem, which behavioral economists describe as the sunk cost fallacy and which feels, when you’re living it, nothing like a fallacy at all. The longer you’re in the relationship, the more you’ve put into it: time, emotional energy, compromises, adaptations, sometimes financial and practical entanglement. The more you’ve invested, the more painful it is to accept that the investment may not pay off, and the more motivated you become to keep investing in hopes of eventual return. This isn’t irrationality. It’s a very human response to loss aversion. But it can keep you in something much longer than the actual evidence warrants, hoping that the next round of effort will be the one that changes things.
What Change Actually Requires
This is not a piece about whether BBMBs can change, because the answer is technically yes and practically rarely. It’s worth being precise about what actual change requires, not to close the door on hope, but to give you an accurate map of what you’d be waiting for.
Genuine change in the patterns that define a BBMB requires, at minimum, that he recognize there is a problem. Not that he acknowledges your unhappiness, which he can do while still maintaining that your unhappiness is not his fault. Not that he agrees things need to be different, which he can do while still believing the things that need to be different are your reactions rather than his behavior. But that he actually sees, with some clarity and some willingness to sit with the discomfort of what he sees, that he has patterns that cause harm and that those patterns are his to change.
Most BBMBs never reach this recognition while inside a relationship, because the relationship provides enough of what they need, including your labor, your patience, your continued presence, to make the discomfort of genuine self-examination feel optional. The painful truth is that for many of these men, if change happens at all, it happens after a significant loss, after relationships fail repeatedly and the pattern becomes too consistent to blame on the other party, after consequences arrive that can’t be externalized. Sometimes even then it doesn’t happen. But within the warm accommodation of a relationship with someone who loves them and is trying very hard, the incentive to change is almost never sufficient.
This is not your fault. It’s not evidence of your failure to love him well enough. It’s the predictable outcome of a system where his needs are being met, where his behavior is being absorbed rather than truly confronted, where the consequences of his dysfunction land primarily on you rather than on him. The system works exactly the way systems work. It doesn’t change until the incentive structure changes.
If change does happen, it typically involves sustained professional therapy with someone experienced in the specific patterns at play, long enough to go beyond surface behavior into the underlying architecture. It involves accountability structures outside the relationship, other people or consequences that don’t disappear when he’s charming or apologetic. It involves time, not weeks but months and years, during which the behavior actually changes rather than the talk about change becoming more sophisticated. And it involves him wanting it, not to get you back or to seem better, but because he has genuinely, unambiguously decided that the person he currently is causes harm he’s no longer willing to cause.
If you are currently watching for evidence of this, ask yourself what you’re actually seeing. Is the behavior changing? Not the words about change, not the tears, not the renewed investment that looks like Stage One of the cycle beginning again. The behavior. What he does when disappointed. What he does when criticized. What he does when he’s wrong. What he does with tasks that are boring and domestic and unglamorous. That’s where change shows up if it’s real, and that’s the only place worth looking.
The Permission You Might Be Waiting For
There’s a specific thing that people who love BBMBs often need and rarely feel they have, so let’s name it directly.
You are allowed to decide that loving someone is not enough of a reason to stay. You are allowed to make decisions based on your own wellbeing rather than exclusively on what you believe he might be capable of someday. You are allowed to conclude that a relationship is not working without having exhausted every possible avenue of intervention, without having stayed long enough to be certain there is no hope, without first ensuring he has everything he needs to potentially be better in the future. You are allowed to leave.
This sounds obvious. It does not feel obvious from inside these relationships. From inside them, leaving often feels like giving up on someone who needs you, like betraying potential you can see even if it’s never quite materialized, like taking the easy way out of something you made a commitment to see through. The BBMB has often spent significant time ensuring it feels exactly this way, not always deliberately, but because his survival strategy involves making your exit feel like your failure.
It isn’t. Recognizing that you cannot fix someone is not failure. It’s clarity, and clarity is one of the most loving things you can extend to yourself when love for someone else has been running out for a long time.
He is not broken. He is built a specific way, by specific forces, for specific reasons, and that construction is very stable because it’s been in place for a very long time. You didn’t build it and you can’t unbuild it. What you can do is decide what you’re willing to live with, what you’re not, and act accordingly.
That decision is yours. It has always been yours. And it doesn’t require you to wait until you’re certain there’s no hope. Sufficient evidence is enough. You don’t need proof of impossibility. You need only to be honest about what the evidence in front of you is actually saying.
The Rise of the Bitch Boy Man Baby examines the psychology, cultural roots, and far-reaching consequences of emotional immaturity in men, from intimate relationships to political leadership. Available now.






